Is Mediation Legally Binding?

Get your
Free Consultation
Custy Law Firm | Accident & Injury Lawyers

September 15, 2023

Is Mediation Legally Binding

A critical issue in an Indiana personal injury case is deciding whether to settle the matter in mediation. Mediation is a guided negotiation process led by a trained mediator to help the two parties involved come to a compromise. Settling your case in mediation can be a great alternative to going to trial. It can save you money and avoid uncertainty about a jury’s actions.

However, like many injured people, you probably wonder, “Is mediation legally binding?” According to Indiana law, parties to mediation must mediate in good faith but are not required to reach an agreement. Mediation itself is not legally binding.

Understanding the Mediation Process

A personal injury mediator is trained to help settle legal matters between the two parties. The role of the mediator isn’t to determine which party is right or wrong. Rather, a mediator helps each side see the other’s perspective and seek compromise. As a neutral third party, the mediator can ask questions about each side’s case and offer suggestions for compromise. Mediators in Indiana are required to be lawyers but can also be judges.

Mediation is confidential, so the parties involved must sign confidentiality agreements. Confidentiality in mediation is binding in Indiana. Often included in these agreements is a clause stating that whatever is said in mediation cannot be used in a trial should the parties not settle the case.

Mediation is non-binding. But, if the parties arrive at a compromise during mediation, the mediator or one of the lawyers can create a settlement agreement. Once both parties sign the agreement, it is a legally binding contract. If a lawsuit has been filed in the case, the contract will be presented to a judge for their approval as a resolution of the case. However, mediation’s chief benefit is allowing the opposing parties to confidentially discuss the matter without being bound by the formal rules of a court.

If a judge orders mediation, participating in it is required under Indiana law. Not participating in mediation would be a violation of a court order.

Does Mediation Mean Settlement?

A mediation discussion is just that – a discussion. The guidance of a mediator can help the injured victim and the at-fault party remain focused on the goal of reaching a settlement. Sometimes, the parties can become contention about particular issues, especially if the question of who is to blame isn’t resolved. A mediator can help calm tempers and maintain amicable interactions.

Mediation doesn’t necessarily result in a settlement. It may take more than one session to reach a compromise on all matters, especially in complex cases. The initial discussion may help both parties reach a compromise. Until there is a written settlement agreement, mediation does not mean settlement. The other party might be unwilling to agree to terms you can live with. In that case, your lawyer may advise going to trial. However, Nothing you discussed or agreed to in mediation may be used at trial because of the confidentiality agreement.

A settlement agreement, on the other hand, is binding. After both parties agree to the specific terms of the settlement, their lawyers can review the proposed agreement, ensuring that the terms of the drafted settlement agreement are the same ones agreed upon in mediation.

Once the settlement agreement is signed and submitted to an Indiana civil court judge, the judge will ensure the contract is legally sound. When the judge signs off on it, it’s just a question of waiting for the at-fault party or their insurance company to cut you a check before your case is concluded.

What If Mediation Doesn’t Lead to a Settlement?

If the parties attend mediation and participate in good faith, it is still possible that no agreement can be reached. In that case, one of two scenarios could result.

If the parties believe they are close to reaching an agreement, they can schedule an additional mediation session.  Then, they can continue to refine their compromises until they come to terms.

If it becomes apparent that no settlement can be reached, the parties can agree to terminate the mediation session and proceed with scheduling the case for trial.

When the case goes to trial, your lawyer will present your case before a judge or jury. The court will listen to the evidence presented by both sides and determine whether the at-fault party was negligent. If the court finds that the at-fault party caused your injuries, the judge or jury also determines how much your award will be.

If your Indiana personal injury lawyer thinks the at-fault party’s behavior was egregious enough to warrant punitive damages, they may advise trialing the case. If you have a jury trial, the jury may also determine whether punitive damages will be assessed against the at-fault party.

Once the jury reaches a verdict, it must be approved by a judge. When that’s finished, if you win, the court will order the liable party to pay you the compensation the judge or jury determined you’re due. The at-fault party or their insurance company will cut your lawyer a check.

The Value of Mediation in Personal Injury Cases

Is Mediation Legally BindingMediation has several benefits. Among them is saving you the expense and stress of a trial. If you go to court, in addition to any court fees and costs, you’ll have to pay for your attorney’s time and the time of any expert witnesses that your lawyer engages to testify on your behalf. In addition, being in court and listening as the other side presents their evidence is stressful.

Mediation is also confidential. Anything said in mediation sessions is confidential, and often, so are the terms of your agreement. If your case goes to trial, the court proceedings and evidence presented all become court records. Many people value their privacy and would rather accept a settlement and put the matter behind them than air their disputes in public court.

However, some injured people may want a trial or be unable to agree to terms offered by the party that harmed them. Whichever position you’re in – seeking mediation or going to trial – you can trust the experience and knowledge of the Custy Law Firm | Accident & Injury Lawyers legal team. Contact us today at (219) 286-7361 for a free consultation with a seasoned Indiana personal injury lawyer.

Related Posts

How to Win at Mediation

Preparing for Personal Injury Mediation

The Dying Civil Jury Trial

In The News
Mar 02
Bicycle Accident Claims & Helmet Laws in Indiana

Cycling offers many benefits, promoting physical health, environmental sustainability, and efficient transportation. However, the consequences can be severe for cyclists involved in collisions with motor vehicles. In Indiana, understanding the […]

Rental Car Cost Coverage After an Accident Explained
Feb 01

You probably rely on your car every day of your life. If your vehicle sustains damage in a collision, you might have to rent a car. Doing so could be […]

Immediate Actions After a Car Accident That’s Not Your Fault in Valparaiso, Indiana
Jan 01

If you’re ever hurt in a car wreck in Valparaiso, Indiana, knowing what steps to take in the immediate aftermath is critical. You may be eligible for compensation if someone […]

How to Win at Mediation
Sep 22

Mediation is a form of alternate dispute resolution. Mediation can consist of settlement negotiations facilitated by a neutral third party between an accident victim and the person responsible for the […]

Is Mediation Legally Binding?
Sep 15

A critical issue in an Indiana personal injury case is deciding whether to settle the matter in mediation. Mediation is a guided negotiation process led by a trained mediator to […]


I originally tried to use our legal counsel from my union. I was getting lowball offers, and after I refused to accept their offer, I was fired by my very own attorney. I was scared out of my mind not only for myself but my family. I was lucky enough to use Brian Custy, after a hard 3 week trial . . . we ended up winning my case and won well into the six figures. I would highly recommend Brian, and I am now proud to call him my friend.


Since day one i have received the best service that anybody can ask for. Mr. Custy and Melissa have been such caring and trustworthy people. They really make you feel like you are #1 and they will go above and beyond for you no matter what. This firm is by far the best around I would recommend them to anybody. Thanks guys you have helped me in so many ways.

- Joel Marquart

Custy Law Firm has redeemed the reputation lawyers face in the legal field. I’m so grateful for their professionalism, their communication skills as well as their knowledge of the law. My experience seemed overwhelming and the process was intimidated until I spoke with Custy, attorney Brown and Mrs. Dunn from the Valparaiso office. They were vigilant in pursuing a great settlement for my family and I, but most importantly they led me through this most difficult time with patience and sound advice. I’d recommend Custy Law to anyone who need representation.

- Yolonda M

Brian and his team were extremely helpful to us in resolving our case (related to personal injury from a traffic accident).  Brian listened to what our goals were for the case and focused on delivering those (vs. trying to maximize his own fees).  He was extremely professional in all of our interactions and responsive to our numerous questions.  We got a very positive outcome, without any significant hassle.  I highly recommend Custy Law Firm!

- Saroj S.

As a medical professional, I would like to testify that Mr. Brian Custy is the best attorney I met in Indiana. I trust his knowledge, experience, and professionalism. The firm is a very friendly one to work with. You will have no regret to use his service as needed.

- Fei L.
View All Testimonials
Illinois State Bar Association Logo
Academy of Truck Accident Attorneys
National Trial Lawyers top 100 Attorneys Logo
NTL Top 10 for Trucking Litigation
National Institute for Trial Advocacy
Indiana Trial Lawyers Assocation
Trial Lawyer's College Thunderhead Ranch Logo
American Association for Justice Logo
National Association of Distinguished Counsels